by Mark Bisset » Mon Apr 11, 2016 11:24 pm
Ray Bell wrote:By all means, Terry, quoting the article would bring those who didn't follow the sport as we did at the time up to date...
However, your next line brings the first contradiction with the page quoted. You were a fan of Leo from the time of the 22, Mark writes that Leo 'made his name' in the 39. But the fact is that he was already a bit of a crowd hero before he stepped into open-wheelers, having gained a lot of followers with his Holden in the closing years of the fifties.
In fact, Leo had a lot of success in the 20s, the 22 (including his first Australian Championship), the 27 and even a Gold Star round win in the 32.
I was present at Longford when Leo and Greg were finalising the purchases of their respective ex-Clark Lotuses. These moves were simply seen as logical progression for these already-successful drivers.
Did I write 'Lotuses'? Yes, I did. I believe the use of 'Loti' is a gaff. The story also says that Leo was a 'front runner' from the time of his purchase, however the car had so many reliability problems that he often missed meetings altogether in 1966.
A fairly serious problem is the reference to John Sheppard, in particular Tom Geoghegan taking a liking 'to his work preparing the Youl brothers Cooper.'
The part of this section that is correct is that the car was housed at the Geoghegans' when racing in Sydney. But the preparation of the John Youl (not Youl brothers) Cooper was in the hands of Geoff Smedley, who moved on to work for Frank Matich after John's retirement. One of his 'offsiders' from his time tooling the Aussie Miller Cooper (installing the Chev V8 etc) was Bruce Burr, who did indeed work his way into the Geoghegan employ. I frankly don't know if Sheppo ever did anything for the Youls, but I suspect Geoff would have mentioned it at some time in one of our many conversations had he done so.
I mentioned above that Leo won a Gold Star event in the Lotus 32. Mark, though, states that Leo had his first Gold Star win at Sandown in the 39. Sure, it was his first Gold Star win in the 39, and also Repco's first V8 Gold Star win, but the broad brush approach makes the statement wrong.
In the same section he mentions Spencer Martin and Kevin Bartlett in BT11a Brabhams, but KB was driving a BT7a, he never raced a BT11a.
Things not mentioned of significance: The major crash at Bathurst in 1968... and taking the outright lap record at Catalina, which I think he did twice.
And, finally, with regard to the 49s and wings collapsing, he fails to note that both cars had this problem at Lakeside.
Some of this could be seen as nit-picking, I would agree. But there are significant errors and that is why I have said I think he should let someone 'who was there' look at his articles before he uploads them.
Guys,
Thanks for the interest in my articles;
1. Of course Leo had been around a while by '66, but he was stepping up to ANF1, which meant something at the time
2. The article was about the 39, it wasn't intended as a Leo career summary, how much context one includes is a judgement call
3.'Loti', 'twas , Wots , babes etc are bits a slang I use and will continue to
4. Sheppo told me the Youl story, he was the guy I spoke to 'who was there' , you couldn't get any more there than the guy who fettled the car
In other stories sometimes I have specific help, like Derek Kneller in the Matich F5000 story sometimes you can get valuable consensus on topics on forums like TNF, when I have referenced that I have attributed
5. Bartlett didn't ever race a Brabham BT7A to my knowledge, the Mildren Intercontinental Brabham KB raced was BT11A 'IC-3-64'
6. Omissions; about 40% of my content is Australiasian, 85% of the readership is global, so I a biasing the minutae around that! an exception was the Matich article I mention above when I 'really went to town' on minutae only really of interest to those of us in this part of the world
7. People gently correct errors in the articles, just drop me a note on the site or email
mailto:?subject=&body= , phone 0419 332342
[quote="Ray Bell"]By all means, Terry, quoting the article would bring those who didn't follow the sport as we did at the time up to date...
However, your next line brings the first contradiction with the page quoted. You were a fan of Leo from the time of the 22, Mark writes that Leo 'made his name' in the 39. But the fact is that he was already a bit of a crowd hero before he stepped into open-wheelers, having gained a lot of followers with his Holden in the closing years of the fifties.
In fact, Leo had a lot of success in the 20s, the 22 (including his first Australian Championship), the 27 and even a Gold Star round win in the 32.
I was present at Longford when Leo and Greg were finalising the purchases of their respective ex-Clark Lotuses. These moves were simply seen as logical progression for these already-successful drivers.
Did I write 'Lotuses'? Yes, I did. I believe the use of 'Loti' is a gaff. The story also says that Leo was a 'front runner' from the time of his purchase, however the car had so many reliability problems that he often missed meetings altogether in 1966.
A fairly serious problem is the reference to John Sheppard, in particular Tom Geoghegan taking a liking 'to his work preparing the Youl brothers Cooper.'
The part of this section that is correct is that the car was housed at the Geoghegans' when racing in Sydney. But the preparation of the John Youl (not Youl brothers) Cooper was in the hands of Geoff Smedley, who moved on to work for Frank Matich after John's retirement. One of his 'offsiders' from his time tooling the Aussie Miller Cooper (installing the Chev V8 etc) was Bruce Burr, who did indeed work his way into the Geoghegan employ. I frankly don't know if Sheppo ever did anything for the Youls, but I suspect Geoff would have mentioned it at some time in one of our many conversations had he done so.
I mentioned above that Leo won a Gold Star event in the Lotus 32. Mark, though, states that Leo had his first Gold Star win at Sandown in the 39. Sure, it was his first Gold Star win in the 39, and also Repco's first V8 Gold Star win, but the broad brush approach makes the statement wrong.
In the same section he mentions Spencer Martin and Kevin Bartlett in BT11a Brabhams, but KB was driving a BT7a, he never raced a BT11a.
Things not mentioned of significance: The major crash at Bathurst in 1968... and taking the outright lap record at Catalina, which I think he did twice.
And, finally, with regard to the 49s and wings collapsing, he fails to note that both cars had this problem at Lakeside.
Some of this could be seen as nit-picking, I would agree. But there are significant errors and that is why I have said I think he should let someone 'who was there' look at his articles before he uploads them.[/quote]
Guys,
Thanks for the interest in my articles;
1. Of course Leo had been around a while by '66, but he was stepping up to ANF1, which meant something at the time
2. The article was about the 39, it wasn't intended as a Leo career summary, how much context one includes is a judgement call
3.'Loti', 'twas , Wots , babes etc are bits a slang I use and will continue to
4. Sheppo told me the Youl story, he was the guy I spoke to 'who was there' , you couldn't get any more there than the guy who fettled the car
In other stories sometimes I have specific help, like Derek Kneller in the Matich F5000 story sometimes you can get valuable consensus on topics on forums like TNF, when I have referenced that I have attributed
5. Bartlett didn't ever race a Brabham BT7A to my knowledge, the Mildren Intercontinental Brabham KB raced was BT11A 'IC-3-64'
6. Omissions; about 40% of my content is Australiasian, 85% of the readership is global, so I a biasing the minutae around that! an exception was the Matich article I mention above when I 'really went to town' on minutae only really of interest to those of us in this part of the world
7. People gently correct errors in the articles, just drop me a note on the site or email [email]mark@bisset.com.au[/email] , phone 0419 332342